Cpm 3v vs vg10. 5% chromium, which helps them resist rust and staining.
Cpm 3v vs vg10 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V 9Cr18MoV vs VG10. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel For carbon steel I would rather see 3V and 10V over M4. But, CPM 3V steel is a lot more durable, especially for outdoor and rugged use. From what I understand it’s edge retention is similar to This is basically what you would expect based on the steels. Reply. Both steels are great choices, but S35VN is generally considered more well-rounded. Thread starter awestib; Start date Oct 31, 2011; awestib. The 154cm steel is often a more common Starting at 6:48, Lynn states that CPM 3V is the strongest steel Cold Steel ever used for its knives, including San Mai and Carbon V. Let me tell you why. Again, in the table, S30V wins in wear resistance, but looking at the bars the difference is not huge. Both AUS-10 and VG10 steels originate from Japan and offer excellent corrosion resistance and edge retention. CPM MagnaCut has high toughness, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance Generally seen as a slight upgrade to the 440C/VG-10/ATS-34 caliber VG-10 is easier to sharpen, somewhat cheaper, and very corrosion-resistant. vg10 vs S30v I think the latter is better over all but I’m K390 steel vs VG10. I am certain that the 3V would be a tougher blade. CPM 3V is often used in knife blades, hunting knives, and other applications that require extreme strength and durability. Comparing LC200N and magnacut is just too apples and oranges. When I say longer, I mean like 30 min - 1h or so CPM 3V vs 5160 Hello, r/knives! I'm looking to get a good sized (over 12 inch) Bowie knife. S30V demonstrates the highest attainable hardness out of these three stainless steels due to its higher alloy content and carbide volume. The main difference between Elmax and CPM 3V steel is that Elmax is stainless steel with excellent corrosion Since there aren’t any considerable differences between the VG10 and 154cm, both can prove to be an excellent fit for knives. Designed by Lynn C. On a chemical and production level, steels like CPM-20CV and Carpenter CTS-204P are both pretty similar to M390. The CPM-3V held an edge long than a Dozier in D2 or a Bark River in A2. 3% CPM 20CV Carbon - 1. That said, since it's a collectible that Knife maker here. This time-tested blade steel is made in Japan and found on a huge range of cutlery including kitchen knives, fixed blades, and pocket knives. 5% which definitely helps with corrosion resistance, although it is not a stainless steel. Nitro-V is stainless steel with great corrosion resistance due to the added nitrogen, but 3V is not stainless steel and will rust when used in corrosive Comparing Steel Types: CPM-3V, S35VN, and MagnaCut Before we delve into the specifics, let's first get a general understanding of these steel types: 1. 1. , estimated). Here is the short answer: CPM-S45VN has a slightly higher amount of chromium and niobium than S30V, which can improve its wear Ocel VG-10 Nožířské oceli - ocele Knives - Knife, folders, fixed blade, utility, pocket, hunting, kitchen, sharpening C-70 Carbon V Cowry X CPM 1V CPM 154 CPM 20CV CPM M4 CPM T420V CPM T440V CPM-10V CPM-15V CPM 3V CPM 9V CPM CRU-WEAR CPM D2 Tool CPM-S110V CPM-S30V CPM-S35VN Cr8Mo2VSi CTS 204P CTS-BD1 CTS XHP CTV2 D2 As mentioned above Sleipner is closer to CPM-D2, CPM-3V's equivalents are PD-1 and Z-ware. CPM 3V. Both 3V and 10V steel belong to the crucible family of high vanadium steel. 3G steel vs VG10. Another popular blade steel is the CPM 3V. Bohler N690Co and VG10 are hugely similar because of the added cobalt in their alloy composition. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA The VG10 is another premium steel grade that is manufactured in Japan and used primarily for manufacturing cutlery. Knifemakers like The main difference between VG-10 and D2 steel is the amount of carbon they contain. I expect Fallkniven to bring several models in laminated Cobalt steel. 5% Vanadium - 2. Both are great For instance, CPM-3V and -4V make the very top of the list. I'd give it a slight nod for edge retention with a nod to VG-10 for taking a finer edge and being slightly easier to sharpen. On the other hand, 154CM shines in corrosion resistance because it is stainless steel; it contains high amounts of Chromium in its element than 10V. 154CM = $208. Feb 8, 2014 #3 Magicatus said: Comparing CPM 3V with other tool steels, it demonstrates better toughness than A2 and D2 tool steels. Joined May 12, 2004 Messages 2,611. Cpm 154 has better edge holding than VG-10, pretty easy to sharpen and good corrosion resistance. They are both made in japan. While CPM 3V is still a relatively hard steel and CPM MagnaCut. It offers excellent wear resistance, retains sharpness for a long time, and is tougher. According to well known table 3V wins in toughness, but in such a small knife (< 3") I don't think it will be a big win for me. Jan 5, 2017 #1 Hows 4v stacking up in the knife world? I haven't seen to many knives in it and such I haven't seen many reviews about. 5 5-5. Joined Feb 6, 2014 Messages 9. Larrin says: April 18, 2020 at 5:09 pm CPM 4V = $253. 3V is by far my absolute favorite steel, its just so tough, and it always seems to hold an edge nearly as good as S30V/S35VN. Due to Elmax having a higher hardness level than VG10 steel the steel wins over VG10 in terms of edge retention, toughness level and wear resistance. Blade HQ opines that CPM-3V and -4V are, “perfect blade steel for a fixed blade knife” because they score high in edge retention In this article, we will be taking a closer look at VG10 and S30V steel, two stainless steels widely used in the manufacture of most knives. If you’re looking for an all-around choice with a greater emphasis on toughness, then the CPM 3V is a terrific choice. Czechmate. VG-10 has a finer grain content Elmax vs VG10. When compared to other popular knife Cpm 3v is a great steel, no doubt, but in therms of toughness it's not in the same league as the S series, or even 5160, 6150, L6, A8mod, Infi, The new low temper heat Nitro-V vs CPM 3V. Oct 2, 2007 #3 That CPM-S35VN is a stainless steel but will not be as tough as 3V. The datasheet for CPM M4 steel shows that it can achieve hardness values in the 59-65 HRC range depending on the austenitizing temperature and tempering conditions. I, for one, have different thoughts in this regard, especially [] To me CS is like distributor - warehouse and it can sell good or bad knives it may be Gerber or some Seki company or something from China with variation of quality you may expect. 3G Steel vs CPM 3V. I am not saying there is no difference at all, but in reality, it is not going to be night and day difference. S35VN, on the other CPM ® 3V: CPM 3V is a high toughness, wear-resistant tool steel made by the Crucible Particle Metallurgy process. Both M390 and CPM 3V are fantastic steels for applications like high-quality knives and tools. They’re actually pretty similar, as well. A CPM 154 knife will thus resist corrosion and rusting better than D2 steel. CPM 3V, or Italian D2. Testing VG-10. Joined Feb 24, 2011 Messages 4,423. 00% VG-10. 5 VG10 Elmax HAP40 S45VN S30V CPM D2 3-3. You can buy knives in 3V,4V with ultimate toughness, but you can also buy steels like Maxamet which 186K subscribers in the knifeclub community. And H1 too. VG10 steel has higher Carbon and Vanadium in its composition than German X50CrMoV15. N690 vs 440C: 440C steel is a high carbon stainless steel often used in knife making. 154CM VG10; EDGE RETENTION: 4/10: 5/10: EASE OF SHARPNESS: 5/10: 6/10: CORROSION RESISTANCE: 6/10: 7/10: TOUGHNESS: 5/10: 4/10: VG10 offers better edge retention, lower toughness and better corrosion resistance With this in mind, Cold Steel created the Nightfall Series - made with the same level of quality and attention to detail as their Japanese classics but trading San Mai for premium American CPM-3V powdered super steel. Proven carbon and tool steels, including CPM 3V. Post by Recently, two newcomers have taken the spotlight: CPM 3V and MagnaCut. It has a higher Rockwell hardness than A2 Tool Steel, ranging from 58 to 61, and is also Available with Japanese VG-10 San Mai III steel, or with American CPM 3-V High Carbon Steel blades, it features a broad blade that's been flat ground to achieve the ideal blade cross-section and edge geometry for hunting application. 30% manganese, and 1. CPM 3V has a greater toughness level than S35VN (also called CPM-S35VN) and S30V (also called CPM-S30V) are both some of the most popular steels used in knife making. Top. In the manufacturer CATRA dataset, CPM Cru-Wear was in between 3V and Vanadis 4E, as would be expected by its carbide content. 30% molybdenum, 0. Most users would never know the difference in these steel varieties. Going to say again, I think most knife users will be hard pressed to notice a difference between S30V, S35VN and S45VN. 5/10 Ease of Sharpening= 4/10 Corrosion Resistance= 4. The alloy composition of VG10 steel is superior to that of DSR-1K6 steel as it contains more carbon, chromium, and also additional elements like vanadium and cobalt which greatly improves its strength over DSR-1K6. We will be comparing these two steels I ‘ve generally found all CPM steels to make a micro lip under chopping impact in soft Maple wood: S30V one to five hits, CPM 154 CM ten hits, 3V about 20-30, all at 20 dps. Joined Aug 4, 2013 Messages Both the 154cm and s30v steels are solid performers built for heavy-duty applications and find their use in cutlery as well. VG-10, N690, CPM-154 and 154CM are finding their way into a lot of moderate priced knives, and even some budget items. It is designed to provide maximum resistance to breakage and chipping in a high wear-resistance steel. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V CPM S30V and CPM 154 are both premium stainless steels manufactured using the Crucible Particle Metallurgy (CPM) technique. Like the 3G, it has high levels of carbon, chromium, and molybdenum. https://www. cpm 4v is just new and not being capitalized yet because not many understand what the advantage to R2 vs VG10. Knives made of VG 10 are nearly as durable as those made of D2, but they also have high corrosion resistance. What it is: VG-10 is a Japanese stainless steel American CPM 3-V can take an extremely fine edge which is highly chip-resistant. 57 posts Previous; 1; 2; 3; Next; butch Member Posts: 1330 Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 4:33 pm Location: littlestown PA USA. D2 vs CPM 3V. Other Knife Steels Comparison with S35VN Steel. So I would use cpm3v for a small/ medium knife DC53 steel vs D2 steel. It’s up there with top tier steels like CPM-S110V, CPM-S90V, Bohler’s M390, Hitachi’s ZDP-189, and Elmax. However, it may be slightly Recently, two newcomers have taken the spotlight: CPM 3V and MagnaCut. Joined Jan 5, 2013 Messages 734. Though costly, this modern tool steel is astonishingly tough and exceptionally wear CPM S30V vs VG10. In-Depth Look at CPM-3V. Now that we have looked at the short answer, we can look at each steel individually, how these steels compare in-depth, and the best knives in each steel. In conclusion, both S35VN and CPM 3V steels from Crucible Industries offer excellent performance for knives, but with distinct Both the 154cm and s30v steels are solid performers built for heavy-duty applications and find their use in cutlery as well. 95; for the precision ground price I used for the examples above, it would be Keffeler once made a two exactly same blade of PD1 which is pretty much Carpenter version of CPM-Cruwear and another in 3V. For toughness and keen edges 3V and When comparing CPM 3V steel vs. 80% carbon, 7. In contrast, D2 tool steel is considered semi-stainless steel. CPM Rex M4 = @$260. PS: I don't mean the 3V is made in Taiwan but the knife is Advantages of CPM-3V as Knife Steel. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V SG2 Knife maker here. Originally developed for high-end kitchen cutlery Additionally, S30V is more expensive than VG-10, which may be a consideration for those on a budget. Oct 20, 2022 #6 llkoolkeg Hairy Flaccid Member. point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V SG2 SUS410 Tanto VG 10 Steel CPM 3V is a very tough tool steel made by the Crucible Particle Metallurgy process. It’s actually not as hard, and The only category where VG-10 beats CPM-3V is corrosion resistance - so at the same price point I go CPM-3V all day long. 95 (I thought 3V would be less than 4V huh). 3G Crucible: CPM-M4, CPM-3V, CPM-4V Generic: A2, O1, D2, 1095. Both CPM 3V steel and CPM CruWear steel are produced by the same company, Crucible industries using the CPM process. They are both absolutely great. The main difference between 3G steel and VG10 steel is that 3G steel is a powder metallurgy-produced steel while VG10 steel is produced conventionally. However, AUS-10 counters with superior toughness and As a stainless steel, CPM SPY27 offers superior corrosion resistance compared to the non-stainless CPM Cruwear, ensuring that the blade remains protected against moisture and harsh environments. com/JOEXSTEEL: VG-10, SAN MAI - BLADE: 6 ", 152 mm Kray-Ex handle - Survival Rescue Knife EXTREME TESTING COLD STEEL SRK VG-10 - ED AR-RPM9 vs VG10 Steel. Cpm-S90V and cpm-3V come to mind Reply reply I've reprofiled and sharpened Delta 3V (and also CPM 20CV) with a $30 Lansky system. It will be interesting to see Welcome to the forum! :) Interesting list! One thing I can't agree on though right away (like Tom): S30V and ZDP 189 same edge retention? Very different from my experience Crucible: CPM-M4, CPM-3V, CPM-4V Generic: A2, O1, D2, 1095. 5 Nitro-V MagnaCut 4V 6-6. So say I wanted to baton wood a lot and do a good bit of chopping without the use of an axe, would the extra little bit of stainless properties and the "super toughness" really be that much better over 5160 and 52100? The CPM 3V sounds like the perfect steel choice for me, then. You're right that CPM154 and not CPM154CM is the official name, but CPM 154 CM is an accurate description of it, so that's used by some, too. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 10Cr15CoMoV vs VG10 . I know, that 3V version was made in Taiwan (black), then in Italy (stonewashed 38CKD) and now they make it in Taiwan again (satin 38CKE). 75% Molybdenum - 1. You are good either way you go. Then come the numbers and letters, such as 8cr, 9cr, 10cr, vg10, 12c27n, 154cm, 14c28n CROMOVA 18 vs VG10. I know a stainless blade is probably going to offend traditional Kephart fans but, from what I can see it has the edge and structural strength of a lot of carbon steels. The 154cm steel is often a more common For carbon steel I would rather see 3V and 10V over M4. For outdoor knives the steel choice may depend on the environment you expect to be in. JUST FOR THE FLAT STOCK of CPM S110V, it is priced at $394. In recent years, it has proved very popular with custom knife makers. Although S35VN has a slightly lower edge retention than VG-10, it compensates with better toughness and easier sharpening. On the other hand, VG10 offers better toughness than its counterpart. Made in Japan by Takefu, it offers good edge retention and stain resistance. CPM-3V is used in many types of knives due to its exceptional toughness and high wear resistance. But the CPM 3V is also easier to sharpen. When I say longer, I mean like 30 min - 1h or so In terms of edge retention and toughness it’s an incremental step up from VG-10. Oct 31, 2011 #1 As you mention Fallkniven, Final thoughts on 3V vs S35VN Steel. M390 can be easier to sharpen and hold a great sharp edge. Oct 2, 2007 #3 That is an interesting question. VG-10. 75% vanadium. I know that 3v is tough, and some say it is barely more corrosion prone than stainless but I don’t know if that’s true. VG-10 has a venerable reputation as an optimal Japanese kitchen knife steel. CPM 3V vs CPM-3V is ~2X tougher than 1095 via notched Charpy (impact toughness) @ 57-58 Rc. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 CPM 3V vs M390 Steel. Elmax vs CPM 3V. How is VG-1 in general compared to VG-10 or say . Post by Doeswhateveraspidercan » Sat Jan 05, 2019 3:30 am. That said, since it's a collectible that you're after, San Mai is prettier to look at. Assuming that you had two (nearly) identical knives, one made N690 vs VG 10. Cpm 3v is a great steel, no doubt, but in therms of toughness it's not in the same league as the S series, or even 5160, 6150, L6, A8mod, Infi, The new low temper heat treatments will increase toughness, sure, but a high carbide steel will never be as tough as simple low/medium carbon steels. 75% vanadium, 1. CPM 3V has a higher carbon content than S35VN, which gives it better wear resistance. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V Why I would argue S35VN is the second most balanced easily affordable steel after CPM Magnacut. Larrin rates the corrosion resistance at 7. VG-10 has a higher level of carbon at 1. It is designed to withstand situations in which breakage and chipping may be common. And, CPM-20CV is the gateway steel to some next level metallurgy. Discuss Spyderco's products and history. Essentially, it’s a more needed up version to the premium S30V, promising improved toughness, wear resistance, edge retention, and corrosion ZDP-189 is also more expensive than VG 10 steel. For CPM 3V a hardness around HRC 60 gives a good mix of toughness and resistance to wear. This 3V is said to be super tough and especially good for large chopping blades. It has good edge retention, corrosion resistance, and toughness. Carefully honed to razor sharpness, its edge cuts effortlessly while its dropped point simplifies the chore of Both the CoS and 3V steel are improvements over more conventional steels like VG10 or A2. Otherwise, go for VG-10. While N690 is similar in its If your goal is to purchase a knife with excellent toughness for heavy-duty cutting, look for knives made from other types of steel with better toughness than Niolox. That's outdated. 5% chromium, which helps them resist rust and staining. It does not meet the amount of chromium elements to make it stainless steel. No reported edge problems, high full points reviews, ease of sharpening on waterstones (not so much Vanadium as cpm 3v or Elmax). From 3V is completely different than s30V. The VG10 is also a very balanced steel alloy, with lots of chromium for corrosion resistance and also vanadium to get more toughness. It offers impact resistance greater than A2, D2, Cru-Wear, or CPM M4, approaching the levels provided by S7 and other shock I've reprofiled and sharpened Delta 3V (and also CPM 20CV) with a $30 Lansky system. But heck, I I noticed in the Production Schedule thread that some upcoming knives are being made out of 3V and S35VN. For wear resistance and edge retention, 3G works best. Much like ATS34 or 154cm. G10 for low-maintenance handles that can really take a beating. Below I have shown the toughness of the low alloy steels vs a Thermo-Calc calculated carbon “in solution” at 1475°F. 5/10 Overall Field Performance= 8. DC53 is an improved version of D2; therefore, they differ in chemical composition. Both are high-performance steels celebrated for their unique properties, revolutionizing how users approach the age-old debate of toughness versus sharpness. Spyderco: NON MULTA SED MULTUM My islands. CPM 3V vs CPM 10V Steel. I think even with the newer supersteels out today, these hold their own as very well-balanced options. CPM 10V steel is harder than 3V. This is one of those comparisons where you’re getting down to splitting atoms. Search Advanced search. They CPM 154 vs D2. I can tell you that CPM 3V at 62 HRC in a light cutting knife will outperform many official premium steels though, combination of toughness and wear resistance is very good. When it comes to edge retention, MagnaCut and CPM 3V perform equally well, making them suitable for tasks that require prolonged CPM S35VN vs VG-10 . For some reason 154CM is particularly popular in automatic knives and VG-10 is aus 8 vs vg10 AUS 8 vs 9Cr18MoV. The 1095 custom with it's superior geometry blew the super steel custom out of the water. NJBillK Custom Leather and Fixed Blade modifications. But to me this laminated VG-1 looks pretty good, I think VG-1 more like VG-10 for big knives and it is laminated which make it more attractive. CPM 3V, [16] a proprietary steel with a very high toughness of less than CPM 1V but more than A2 along with high wear resistance that is better than CPM 1V. I have a BR Scandi in 3v, the F1 in VG-10, F1 in 3G and the F1 Pro in Cos. In context, steels like CPM 154, D2 steel, and Bohler N690, which are similarly priced, will offer better toughness than Niolox. And for a In addition to the VG-10, N690, 154CM, CPM-154, and ATS-34 mentioned in the thread so far, there's also RWL-34 and 10Cr15CoMoV, which are also pretty much the same. On the other hand, the steel has relatively better corrosion resistance than non-stainless steels like 5160 and 52100. Neither is corrosion resistant. Re: Cpm s30v vs. CPM 3V = $257. knivesandguns. D2 is a semi-stainless steel that has better edge retention, and grid ability and is also easier to sharpen. It is true that LC200N, 154CM and 440C were all developed for ball bearings and that M390 and many others were designed for plastic molds and other industrial applications. CPM M4 vs S30V Steel Comparison Table Hardness. Real, good Italian and or American D2 is also really American CPM 3-V can take an extremely fine edge which is highly chip-resistant. 05%, while D2 has a lower level of carbon at Some steels did a bit better or worse than expected like Z-Max, S110V, or Blue Super, and those deviations were discussed, some have more pleasing hypotheses than The San Mai VG1 vs VG10 steel core pro's & con's? Thread starter PocketKnifeJimmy; Start date Nov 2, 2021; PocketKnifeJimmy. In principle 3V should be superior, because it should have higher toughness and higher abrasion resistance, but some Was CPM-20cv in the conversation? Looks like they were looking for better edge retention and corrosion resistance without sacrificing too much toughness; it doesn’t get more balanced than 20cv in that regard. VG10 is a more newbie friendly steel offering good performance while still being easy to sharpen. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket CPM S45VN steel, developed by Crucible Industries, is a martensitic stainless steel known for its improved properties compared to its predecessor, S35VN steel. VG10. CPM-3V is a tool steel known for its extreme toughness and ability to withstand heavy-duty use. S30V contains 4% vanadium which facilitates substantial hard vanadium carbide formation, allowing it to reach hardnesses up to 64 HRC with optimal heat According to the chemical composition and the HRC of the steel, the CPM S30V Steel has the following features: Edge Retention: With a maximum of 61HRC due to the mixture of Tungsten, Vanadium, Manganese, and Carbon, the CPM S30V offers a great hardness followed up by an excellent Edge Retention. S30V and M4 steels exhibit different hardness characteristics that can impact their knife application performance. Post CPM 3V, made by the Crucible Particle Metallurgy process, is designed to provide maximum resistance to breakage and chipping in a highly wear-resistant tool steel. Hard carbon steel is sandwiched between two layers of tough lower In an attempt to shed light on this subject, this article will present a comprehensive comparison between two favored knife steel types: Crucible Industries’ S30V (CPM S30V) and My honest opinion of the two is S30V is only slightly better than VG-10. Let’s take a look at how it compares to a few key steels such as 440C, D2, S30V, M390, and VG10. Elmax Steel vs CPM 3V. 00% Vanadium - 4. I bookmarked your home page. The choice ultimately comes down to taste. CPM 3V will get stained more than M390 but will be more reliable in the field. 4116 5160 Steel vs CPM3V – What’s the Difference By Abhishek Modak July 26, 2023 July 26, 2023 As a knife enthusiast or maker, choosing the right steel is vital to ensure your S90V vs VG-10 steel. buymeacoffee. VG-10 –A high-carbon stainless steel popular in kitchen knives (though not exclusively) VG-10 holds a good edge and is able to resist rust. Used by several custom knife makers and factories, including Jerry Hossom, Mike Stewart [Bark River], Reese Weiland, Nathan Carothers, and Dan Keffeler. H. If you are looking for a knife blade with excellent toughness you will never go VG-10 is a very good using steel, but CPM-S30V is in another class altogether. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta Cpm 154 does better primarily because of the powdered metallurgy process that makes the grains of additives in the metal very small which improves the qualities of the steel by a small amount. It contains cobalt, however, so it’s forged in a different manner. Was CPM-20cv in the conversation? Looks like they were looking for better edge retention and corrosion resistance without sacrificing too much toughness; it doesn’t get more balanced than 20cv in that regard. With the short answer out of the way, we can look in-depth at each steel, what they are made of, how they compare to each CPM 3V vs Fallknivens 3G. VG10 is slightly more renowned for its ability to maintain a sharp edge due to its higher carbon and chromium content, making it a favorite in high-end kitchen knives. G Russell, etc use. 440 or 420 is also old and bad. VG1 steel vs VG10 steel. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point CPM-3V for maximum toughness, CPM-154 for higher corrosion-resistance. them in an article about though steels is like writing an article about typical cutlery steels and leaving out VG10. CPM-3V - byla vyrobena v procesu CPM, tato ocel je velmi odolná proti bočnímu namáhání, tedy zlomení páčením. Like ELMAX, it does a great job holding an edge, but it performs really well across the When comparing CPM 3V steel vs. 3V is more corrosion resistant than A2 as far as I know, obviously Elmax and S35VN are stainless, Although the two steel types in S30V vs. For toughness, ease of sharpening, edge stability and strength, and VG 10 steel is better than DSR-1K6 steel in most aspects including corrosion resistance, edge retention, and wear resistance. Feb 7, 2014 #7 Thanks. I use this when making knives for people that don’t know how to care for a high carbon steel. It took a little longer than on the KME or WE, but it worked fine. N690 steel and VG 10 steel are closely related knife steels due to the presence of cobalt in both of their alloy composition, and both are popular due to their I ‘ve generally found all CPM steels to make a micro lip under chopping impact in soft Maple wood: S30V one to five hits, CPM 154 CM ten hits, 3V about 20-30, all at 20 dps. I noticed that all the GSO Survival knives handles were canvas micarta and none were G10, so I was wondering if it were stronger than G10 The CPM-3V held an edge long than a Dozier in D2 or a Bark River in A2. 5 4-4. One might infer that CPM-3V could then be made 2x thinner than 1095 and retain the same toughness, but the Charpy values are based on a standardized sample, it may not be (indeed probably not) a linear change as the sample is reduced to a much thinner cross-section or S30V vs CPM 154 vs 154CM comparison table Hardness. Both steels have similar toughness. VG-10 is a popular Japanese stainless steel known for its excellent edge retention and corrosion resistance. I am looking at a Bark River for Christmas, but they are a bit costly. Both are high-performance steels celebrated for their unique properties, revolutionizing how users CPM 3V, or Italian D2. I use this when making knives for people that don’t I read (somewhere that I don't recall) that the CoS offers 150% of the edge retention of the VG-10 version and the 3G F1 provides 200% of the VG-10 edge retention. D2. What it is: CPM 3V is a "Crucible Particle Metallurgy" carbon tool steel, widely regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V CPM S45VN steel, developed by Crucible Industries, is a martensitic stainless steel known for its improved properties compared to its predecessor, S35VN steel. Between CPM-3V and 5160 spring steel, which is tougher? I did see a graph in an article showing that 5160 is tougher at certain hardnesses, but I'd be interested in knowing if any of you have more And, CPM-20CV is the gateway steel to some next level metallurgy. . 5 CPM154 Vanax K390 10V M2 XHP S35VN 4-4. I have a blade in 3v that developed a bit of pitting over a single days use in muddy wet conditions. Blerv Member Posts: Posts: 2618 Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2018 12:31 am. Tool steel like D2 or CPM-3V is often preferred for its toughness and can withstand harsh conditions. What I don't know, is whether CPM-3V is actually tougher than a high carbon steel without any chromium. Darn near a dead thread but did a google search and was amused. S45VN is a new powder metallurgy stainless steel being produced by Crucible that has just been announced. 5 420A 154 CM D2 M390 S110V S90V BD1N 440C 20CV N690 204P N690Co vs VG10. Real, good Italian and or American D2 is also really impressive, much better than the chinese stuff that Civivi,Kizer,A. VG-10 (B / W) - podobné složení s ocelí VG-1, navíc kobalt a vanad. Heat Treatment - Heat treatment effects the edge retention and VG10 has a slightly higher carbon content, resulting in better hardness and edge retention, while S30V offers improved toughness and corrosion resistance. A2 steel, 3V is superior in edge retention and toughness with a big win for CPM 3V. 5 8-8. If my 3V's are sharp, my VG-10 is razor sharp. com I can't compare for heavy duty use, I have used only INFI for that purpose. I know the Elmax will be more corision resistant but I have heard 3V is amazingly corision resistant for being a carbon steel. AUS-10 vs AUS-8 Steel. Vg10. . CPM 3V exhibits higher toughness compared to MagnaCut, though MagnaCut reaches toughness levels comparable to some non-stainless tool steels. Edge Retention. Crucible Industries as an upgrade to what lots of knife-smiths considered as “the best knife steel available,” the CPM S30V, a lot can be expected from the CPM S35VN. The similarities in corrosion resistance can be attributed to the comparable chromium and molybdenum contents in the two steels, as these elements play a crucial role in promoting CPM Cru-Wear vs CPM 3V. It’s a great stainless. He did some destructive test on both blade to see how the steel hold up and the result is 3V is significantly tougher than PD1. We’ll compare both on their usability and specification before picking out some top knife models, to arm you with all the knowledge you need to Edge Retention: With 58-60HRC steel, the CPM 3V Steel is a hard steel that gives great edge retention. CPM 10V offers better wear resistance and edge retention than 154CM. 5 7-7. CPM 154 vs. VG10 is popular knife steel and offers a good balance of all its properties. M390 has great edge retention–among the best in the knife industry. Hope this helps For carbon steel I would rather see 3V and 10V over M4. Joined Mar 27, 2014 CPM-S30V and CPM-S45VN are two high-performance stainless steels used in knife making. CPM 3Voffers impact toughness greater than A2, D2, CPM Cru-Wear orZ-Wear PM and CPM M4, approaching the levels of S7 and other shock resistant grades, yet it provides excellent wear CPM 3V is one of the toughest tool steels available, especially interesting considering its high wear resistance. 5 LC200N Cru-Wear 7-7. Additionally, SPY27’s finer carbide structure and composition tailored specifically for knives result in enhanced grindability and sharpening ease, allowing for more My steel choices are down to either CPM 3V or CPM Magnucut from the two knifemakers I am choosing between. In terms of edge retention, CPM 3V is considered inferior to M4 and CPM M4. But users should remember that these CPM-3V –A high toughness, wear resistant steel made utilizing Crucible Powder Metallurgy. TAI PAN (CPM 3V) Rating * Name Email * Review Subject * Comments * Like its serpent namesake, the Tai Pan® is aggressively fast and deadly. CPM 4v vs CPM 3v. Jul 21, 2009 #4 From what I've heard, All are very similiar in my experience, S30V is a little tougher than 154cm, and will hold an edge slightly longer than both, but the trade off is it will also be slightly more difficult to 3G steel vs VG10. The CPM-3V Tai Pan features a beautiful double edge blade honed to a screamingly sharp edge and durable Kray-Ex handle with About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright CPM 10V vs 154CM. Comparing CPM Cru-Wear and CPM 3V reveals: Wear Resistance: CPM Cru-Wear offers better wear resistance than CPM 3V due to its higher amount of carbides and air-hardening process. 3G The lower Rockwell hardness also means that CPM 3V is less prone to chipping or breaking during the sharpening process. Its balanced formula emphasizes reliable toughness, acute edges, and lasting corrosion CPM S45VN steel is among the latest steels on the market, developed around 2019; it is already popular among knife makers and other industries. Best known for its high One was 1095 and the other 3v. With this in mind, we created the Nightfall Series - Made with the same level of quality and attention to detail as our Japanese classics but trading San Mai® for premium American CPM 3V powdered super steel. When compared to other popular knife steels, such as D2 and VG-10, 154CM steel offers similar performance characteristics. The choice CPM 3V: CPM 3V, made through powder metallurgy, features 0. Dobrá odolnost proti opotřebení a odolnost vůči korozi. CPM 154 steel is pure stainless steel that is better at resisting wear and corrosion than D2. Would have liked to see data for 3V and AEB-L too. CPM S35VN = $275. Sharpening Niolox Steel. CPM 3V steel vs S35VN: Which Steel Is Right for You? CPM 3V and S35VN are both high-performance tool steels that are known for their toughness, corrosion resistance, and edge retention. 00 (No 5/32 avail. Abrasive wear resistance Toughness 3-3. Find out if it is good steel for your knife! 154CM VS VG10. In If you need a good edge, go for D2. I have complete faith in VG-10. In principle 3V should be superior, because it should have higher toughness and higher abrasion resistance, but some CPM 3V vs M390 Steel. These steels have distinct properties, making them ideal for different applications and preferences. However, there are some key differences between the two steels. CPM 3V also has 7. Though costly, this modern tool steel is astonishingly tough and exceptionally wear It is better than some popular knife steels like CPM 154, AISI 440C steel, and VG 10 steel. While it is more difficult to grind than a simple non alloyed steel such as 1095, 80crv2, AEB L, or 52100, it is easier to grind than many of the higher HRC, larger grain, higher vanadium steels that are very common in the knife world today such as S30V, M390, M4, even S45VN. While both steels are highly CPM 3V Carbon - 0. San Mai is a sandwich consisting of 3 layers of low-end steel (VG1 or Aus8 core, with 420 cladding). At the end performance wise I think it all CPM-3V us extremely tough, sharp, and is semi-stainless. The CPM 3V Magnum Tanto XII is honed to a screamingly sharp edge. It is however slightly less compared to other premium steels like S30V steel and S45VN Knife Steel. CPM 3V vs CPM M4 vs S30V Steel Comparison Table Hardness. Both ZDP-189 steel and S30V steel are premium steels but with different properties. Both types of steel are Both AUS 10 steel and VG-10 steel are stainless steels with high Chromium content. Post by Franco G » Sun Apr 20, 2014 3:39 pm. CPM 3V is another Crucible Industries tool steel, known for its exceptional toughness and decent wear resistance. 00% Molybdenum - 1. H2 vs. 50% chromium, 2. Besides, while on google you can do this - cpm-3v vs infi site:bladeforums. TomAiello Member Posts: 6706 3v has a fine grain pattern, low HRC in the 58-60 HRC range and 2. Corrosion Resistance: Being a stainless Steel CPM S30V Offers a Exploring the Steel Landscape: MagnaCut vs CPM-3V. vg10 vs S30v I think the latter is better over all but I’m CPM-S30V vs CPM-3V What are your thoughts about theses two steels for a small fixed blade (less than 3") At this moment I'm leaning towards S30V. They offer the same level of corrosion resistance and ease of sharpness. I wrote the title wrong, it should be most balanced and affordable steel as CPM MagnaCut is basically just starting to emerge in the knife world. VG10 is mid-range steel that is affordable in terms of price, and corrosion resistance and is also easy to sharpen. 440C The comparison between 154cm and d2 steel is going to be an interesting one. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN S45VN S90V This complete guide covers all the important aspects of CPM 154 steel. 154CM is easier to sharpen and affordable. The CPM 3V equals the corrosion resistance of the Elmax steel. History of S45VN. CPM CruWear vs 3V steel. Well, d2 steel is significantly tougher than the 154cm steel variety and most people even consider it to be the better one out of the two. MagnaCut, being a stainless steel, offers superior corrosion resistance compared to CPM 3V. and I can get a better edge on VG-10 than 3V. In other words, there are other tougher tool steels, AISI S1 steel for example, but none that have comparable wear resistance. S45VN Steel vs. MagnaCut vs CPM 3V: Both MagnaCut and CPM 3V are known for their toughness and ability to withstand high impact and pressure. Developed by Crucible Industries, both steels are popular choices due to their excellent balance of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance. CPM-20CV might be toward the bottom of the list of premium steels, but it’s really really good. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 VG10 has roots in horticultural knife use. 8% Chromium - 7. In the realm of high-performance steel, there are few contenders that steel enthusiasts and knife makers find as intriguing as Crucible CPM MagnaCut and CPM-3V. 5/10 ELMAX: Thanks to John Dyess, Michael Foote, Xun Fan, and Mark Vanderwest for becoming Knife Steel Nerds Patreon supporters!. 4116 12C27 14C28N 440A 440B 440C steel 1060 1095 52100 AEB-L ApexUltra blue steel Chef knife Chef Knives CPM 3V CPM 4V CPM 154 CROMOVA Cronidur 30 D2 steel Damascus drop point Elmax FRN G10 grivory H1 H2 LC200N M390 MagnaCut MC66 Micarta n690 pocket knife Rex 45 rex 121 s30v S35VN X50CrMoV15 vs VG10. ZDP-189 vs S30V steel. Hailing from Japan, VG-10 stainless steel has rightfully earned the moniker "samurai steel" for its prowess in blades. 9/10, the edge retention at around 480 TCC (just above 440c, just Both VG 10 and ATS 34 are Japanese steel but VG10 steel is popular steel with kitchen and outdoor knives while ATS 34 steel is more popular in pocket knives. Both 9Cr18MoV and VG10 steel are budget-made steels. The toughness factor makes the It's similar in composition to VG10 if that helps you any. Frank . neilblade. Joined Mar 6, 2008 Messages 3,200. LC200N is shown to be as tough CPM 4V steel comparison with other knife steels CPM 4V vs. CPM S30V = $270. Having learned the chemical composition and individual properties Both VG10 and S30V offer excellent corrosion resistance, but VG10 tends to have a slight edge in this regard due to its higher chromium content. The ease of sharpening steel is determined by its wear One source speculated that edge retention should be about the same as AEB-L, another source that tested the steel showed an impressive result showing higher edge retention than many popular steels including s35vn, Cpm 154, d2, 3v ect. S30V contains 4% vanadium which facilitates substantial hard vanadium carbide formation, allowing it to reach hardnesses up to 64 HRC with optimal heat Hey guys, i own SRK in SK5 and Compact, i have tried san mai version (VG10), but i didn't like sheet retention most among other things. It is a high alloy stainless steel boasting excellent The title of the first pdf is "Datasheet CPM 154 CM ET comments", and a a lot of suppliers, along with some custom makers, do list it as CPM 154 CM, since it is 154 CM made through the CPM process. Cpm-3v is tough, but is a tool steel, between stainless and carbon steel rust wise. Either will be great depending on use. Its true shining point is corrosion resistance really. 3V is non stainless. It takes a great working edge even at lower angles that’s pretty easily stropped back to slicey. Yes, the Elmax is harder and thus better at retaining its sharp edge and resisting wear. Thanks to Niagara Specialty Metals for getting me a bar of S45VN for the experiments necessary for this article. CPM 3V is powdered supersteel and easily one of the best knife steels in the world. I would like to buy this knife in 3V steel. Both are excellent. Joined Dec 29, 2008 Messages 1,647. N. Thread starter lobo9er; Start date Jan 5, 2017; lobo9er. HoB. Due to its hardness, VG CPM 154 vs. Now that we have looked at the short answer, we can look at each steel individually, how these steels compare in-depth, and CPM S30V and CPM 154 are both premium stainless steels manufactured using the Crucible Particle Metallurgy (CPM) technique. In fact, they both have the same carbon and chromium content, and from tests, appear to perform about the same. However, VG-10 steel offers much better rust resistance. **The first rule of KnifeClub** is to talk about KnifeClub! Bring a friend! This Subreddit is based off S30V vs CPM 154 vs 154CM comparison table Hardness. What is the difference between VG10 vs S30V steel? We’ll take a closer look. I would not expect VG-10 to be significantly better, but you could just have a VG-10 blade which is a little harder than average, has a little less austenite than VG-10 stainless steel edge retention is on par with other steel like N690 Knife steel, CPM 154 steel, and CPM 3V knife steel. That test only tested one knife in nitro v vs many in the other steels VG max vs other steels VG Max vs VG 10 steel. VG10 is a Japanese steel with better corrosion resistance but poor toughness than CPM 154. (What is weird is that I note Cold Steel using it). Overall, both VG-10 and S30V are excellent choices for knife enthusiasts, and the You can find a similar level of toughness in blades made of 420HC, AEB-L steel, and CPM 3V. Cru-Wear (non-CPM) matches the toughness of S35VN despite being a conventionally produced ingot steel. The CoS from FK is also around HRC 60 and it's the same thing here, a good mix of toughness and wear-resitance. Franco G Member Posts: 323 Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 4:33 pm Location: Zagreb Croatia. Crucible industries produce both steels, and 4V is an upgrade of 3V steel. Whether you’re a knife VG-10 (B / W) - podobné složení s ocelí VG-1, navíc kobalt a vanad. CPM S45VN is considered an upgrade to the popular S35VN steel. 3V and CPM Cru-Wear have decent edge retention, with CPM Cru-Wear being a bit better. VG10 provide excellent qualities for a knife blade, there are identifiable differences. CPM S30V steel comparison 440C vs S30V. Generally, though, M390 is going to be a more popular steel you’ll encounter in comparison to the other steels. For such a long knife, I'd like a very tough steel. M390 or CPM-S30V ? For thinnish shortish fixed blade use. They can perform the same kind of tasks with an equally promising efficiency so you can go for The other options for this knife as far as I know are A2, S35VN, and Elmax. CPM-S35VN is a stainless steel but will not be as tough as 3V. Joined Nov 9, 2009 Messages 44,314. 5 9-9. 3V is about 100% tougher than A2 or O1 and has better rust preventative characteristics than either, but is not classified as a stainless steel. Vzhledem k obsahu vanadu má jemnější disperzi zrn ve srovnání s VG-1. It offers excellent wear resistance and S35VN is usually closer to ELMAX or CPM-154, where VG-10 is usually closer to 154CM. Řada REX Now I already know CPM 3V is sometimes referred to as a semi stainless, close, but not stainless and I know it's supposed to be super tough stuff. 00% silicon. Shun VG Max steel is an improvement of VG-10. AUS10A Steel vs VG10. 5 14C28N 3V AEB-L 8-8. 95. CPM-3V: Known for Starting at 6:48, Lynn states that CPM 3V is the strongest steel Cold Steel ever used for its knives, including San Mai and Carbon V. It's also prone to corrosion if not maintained well, which is a downside. Corrosion Resistance: Even if it’s not stainless steel, the CPM 3V Steel has more than 7% of chromium, which makes it great for VG-10 San Mai® comprises of three layers of expertly laminated stainless steel combined in one blade. Spy27 has a reduced carbide volume and finer carbides then VG-10 and SG2 but is able to match these steels in wear resistance thanks to trading out some of the chromium carbides Cpm s30v vs. It’s also got some pretty decent toughness and something like CPM 3V has incredible toughness while very good edge retention, and is still only moderate on the strain to re-sharpen when needed. It contains more carbon, Chromium, and Vanadium hence offering better edge retention, corrosion resistance, and toughness. Thompson in the distinctive “Tanto” style, the Tai Pan® embodies all the best features of a classic dagger while minimizing its shortcomings. RevDevil. R2 steel is harder than VG10 steel, making it better in wear resistance and edge retention. Stainless steels, like VG-10 and 440C, contain at least 10. CPM-3V: Toughness/Durability= 9/10 Edge Retention= 7. Knife steel nerds has an article on 3V you should look it up. In this comprehensive exploration, we’ll dive deep into the attributes of each steel, guided by detailed VG10 and S35VN have comparable corrosion resistance ratings, with VG10 scoring 7 out of 10 and S35VN scoring 7 out of 10 on a general 10-point corrosion resistance rating scale. Good luck both are good steels. Heat Treatment - Heat treatment effects the edge retention and Toughness. 5 8Cr M4 AUS 8 5-5. My I haven't found S30V to be all that superior to VG-10. When looking at popular stainless steels, S30V and S35VN offer AUS 10 vs VG10. I no longer own the 3v blade. It is a high alloy stainless steel boasting excellent The CPM-3V held an edge long than a Dozier in D2 or a Bark River in A2. 5 6-6. Oct 9, 2014 #5 N690 steel is a high-quality stainless steel with properties that put it in the same league as some other well-known knife steels. But it doesn’t mean that there has never been a blade specific steel. CPM 154 has more chromium elements in its composition than D2 making it stainless steel. 90% Chromium - 20. CPM-3V - byla vyrobena v I am not sure if CPM-MagnaCut would knock out my desire for knives in CPM-Cruwear, CPM-3V, Delta 3V, CPM-4V, K390, A2, O1, etc for certain types of knives though. And as with folders, I find it likely that me sweating on the blade on my belt would be a source of potential damage. On paper the 3v should have spanked the 1095 and indeed it was probably tougher, more stain resistant, and held it's edge longer but then I used both knives. ooqegcqykpxjfsaxypdamxfaraqyrybyrbzleijhzlmvrugyommw